(Nov. 1, 2008)
When state auditors called Brian Terrell wanting to see his firm's books, he thought
he had nothing to hide.
"There's absolutely no reason I should have stood out. We were small, maybe $400,000 in revenue, I thought I was doing
everything correct," Terrell says of his Dallas-based business.
Because Terrell & Terrell, CPAs, was so small, the auditor evaluated all
the firm's invoices for the past four years and found a $4,000 variance in state and local tax (commonly called SALT) it had
failed to collect.
"That was embarrassing because the first thing they encourage you to do is call your customers," Terrell
says. "Imagine buying a car and getting a call saying, "We forgot to charge you tax, would you mind paying
it?' I wrote the best letter, asking if there's any way they could help me and a lot of the customers wrote the checks."
Terrell's experience is not unique. Most companies learn about SALT in a reactive
way and come running to their accountants when they encounter problems. A bigger problem is that a lot of those accountants
don't know much about SALT, either, or don't want to take on the liability.
"I started searching for someone to help me similar to the way a tax preparer would in an IRS
audit, but it didn't exist," Terrell says. "I was sharing an office with five other CPAs doing tax work day in and day out,
and they wouldn't even touch it. They knew anyone calling [for advice] was in a mess."
That was 12 years ago and Terrell has since gone on to become a Sage Accpac
reseller who recently took on a project as part of his other company, CodePartners,
to integrate a Web-based sales and use tax software called SpeedTax into Accpac
so that the compliance work could take place behind the scenes for his customers, with transaction-based pricing ranging from
10 to 45 cents.
With some experts predicting an average of two changes in sales tax rates each day, companies either need to bring in a
SALT specialist or install software such as SpeedTax that provides real-time calculations, integrates into their accounting
system and provides detailed reports in case an auditor comes knocking, allowing them to be proactive instead of reactive,
SpeedTax, Avalara, Sabrix and other sales tax software vendors have established
referral programs for accountants to send their clients to them for help. About 250 to 300 firms are part of Avalara's Accountants
Network, which essentially serves as a referral service, according to Marshal Kushniruk, executive
vice president of strategic accounts and customer experience for Avalara.
"The value proposition for accounting firms is they don't want to do the tedious calculations, but they can fulfill returns
for clients or have us do it," Kushniruk says.
The challenge the vendors are facing is that many companies that have problems don't even know they have a responsibility
to collect state and local tax and many accountants don't know how to determine which of their clients fall into that category.
Avalara provides a Perfect Prospect Profile to characterize which companies
may be targets. Red flags go up for those entering a new market, doing business in more than one state, having offices in
more than one state, conducting business on the Web, and recently undergoing an audit (a statistic offered by SpeedTax states that more than 45 percent of companies that purchase technology to ensure "accuracy
and a defensible audit trail" do so after an audit).
Sales tax compliance is a tricky business and a bulk of firms may never hear their clients utter the phrase until they
Software vendor SpeedTax has put together a free CPA Questionnaire online that
accountants can send to their clients to answer and return to them via email.
It was designed to educate clients while collecting key information about potential risks that accountants could use as
a "springboard for corrective action," according to the company.
The multiple-choice survey takes about 15 minutes to complete, but it can be saved and reopened in case clients don't know
the answers to certain questions (Not sure is a choice, however). After completion, a compliance snapshot appears detailing
risk from low to high in the form of dashboards broken into seven categories-audit defense, nexus, taxability, returns and
filing, exemptions and current practices. The client can then add comments before emailing it to his accountant.
Sample questions include:
* What sort of sales tax calculation software or service do you use?
* Do you have a system in place for filing, storing and managing exemption certificates?
* What percentage of your customers are exempt?
* How many sales and use tax returns will you file this year?
* Do you itemize your products versus service on invoices or contracts?
* How many SKUs are represented in your product line?
The full survey is available at www.speedtax.com/questionnaire/index.php
SpeedTax created a free online CPA Questionnaire that allows accountants to determine their
clients' sales tax audit risk. (See related story, "Compliance Checkup.")
Last October, CCH expanded its offerings to include a suite of products called
CorpSystem for corporate tax professionals to not only calculate rates but determine their end-of-month liability, prepare
returns and manage their exemption certificates (which are sometimes required to prove they were not required to collect taxes).
The Tax & Accounting business of Thomson Reuters has a sales tax compliance
product line called OneSource Sales & Use Tax, which it markets to larger companies with multinational operations, and
also offers various guides for users to understand the ins and outs of SALT.
In May, the Tax & Accounting business of Thomson Reuters launched a consulting
services arm that competes with the Big Four and second-tier accounting firms to provide such things as taxability analysis
studies, nexus determination to see if they even are obligated to collect taxes in the first place based on their legal presence
in certain states and voluntary disclosure agreements to reduce penalties for unremitted tax.
They also can evaluate merger and acquisition targets so companies can be alerted to possible exposures and potentially
negotiate purchase prices as a result, according to Rachel Stephens, manager of
Consulting & WorkFlow Services for the Tax & Accounting business of Thomson Reuters,
adding that services cost roughly $250 per hour.
Vendors aren't the only ones looking to help firms help their clients.
Several consulting firms exist throughout the country that will work with clients directly,
in conjunction with their accountant or behind the scenes.
Wendy Ezell started her Grapevine,
Texas-based practice after serving as a SALT specialist for both Arthur Andersen
and Grant Thornton. When she handles federal tax returns for clients, she interviews
them about their overall business to determine if they may have sales tax issues.
"I often find they are making attempts to [collect taxes], but aren't doing it properly. I attempt to get them healthy
and into remittance," says Ezell, whose clients range from small mom and pops
to companies with $75 million in revenue. "A good CPA would have to take notes and listen for clues."
One of the most obvious clues is when a company ventures into another state, Ezell says,
noting that what's taxable in one state may not be taxable in another. For example, a client may boast that he sold $10,000
into Montana for the first time.
"They think they're being friendly, but they're really giving me what information I need and they didn't realize why they
had to tell me," she says.
Accountants who are looking to identify which of their clients may encounter nexus issues should
run a report with revenue by state, and start managing the top 10 states, doing voluntary disclosure to get them in compliance
before the state tries to, Ezell advises.
It's always better if clients tell their accountants they are planning to do something beforehand. For example, Pennsylvania
penalizes companies that don't sell a certain amount into the state, which can end up costing them more than they collected
in revenue there, Ezell says.
Another example boils down to local jurisdictions that may offer incentives for businesses considering opening new facilities
in the area.
"It's rare you can get incentives after you signed a lease and broke ground," says Diane Yetter,
president of Yetter Consulting Services, a sales tax consulting firm based in
Yetter started her career as a sales tax auditor for the state of Kansas in
1985 and served as a sales tax manager at Arthur Anderson in 1989 and also helps clients with systems analysis and software
implementation. She works closely with about 15 CPA firms throughout the country, sometimes billing them and sometimes billing
the client, depending on the firm's desires and the complexity of the situation.
Yetter believes her firm has been successful because she doesn't do income tax work or general
business consulting, so other accountants don't fear they may lose business to her.
"Companies are relying on their CPAs to make sure they're legitimate. If the CPA doesn't know when the company is doing
something that's putting the company at risk, the CPA is putting themselves at risk," Yetter says.
"CPAs have an ego of feeling they can be everything to the client. By not bringing in the specialist, you are at greater risk
of losing your client. If the state assesses them $1 million and it's going to put the company out of business, you can bet
the company is going to sue the CPA."
States are growing more aggressive about going after people who don't pay as the economy worsens and they need to fill
their coffers, Ezell says. (Estimates show about 50 percent of state revenue comes
from sales and use tax and billions of dollars go uncollected every year.)
They are lurking at truck stops to watch how many times trucks cross the state borders, checking Yellow Pages to see where
companies are advertising and looking at Web sites with pull-down menus to see in which states they are willing to take on
Sabrix research found that the total cost of compliance for small businesses
is $130,000 a year, including $10,000 on penalties and interest.
Sabrix, whose pricing is tiered and starts around $1,000 per month for 40,000 transactions
annually, doesn't do audit work, but does provide legal citations of how it calculated rates and provides Web-based portals
to archive key data. The company also offers the firms that are part of its referral network access to a Sales and Use Tax
Webinar forum to help explain a variety of issues including regional trends and shifting nexus definitions.
"We're trying to help them see the risks for clients and help them keep their income work so [their clients] will not go
to a bigger firm," says Carla Yrjanson, Sabrix's
vice president of tax research. "The risk of not coming forward is you're entering a fraud situation and they'll go back and
asses until the beginning of time and add interest and penalties. If you come forward and negotiate to get in compliance,
you have some control, can reduce penalties and reduce or eliminate interest."
Charles Collins, vice president of government affairs for ADP/Taxware,
doesn't necessarily agree that the states have been any more aggressive than they were five years ago, but he does see more
states-about 17-implementing sales tax holidays in which certain products such as clothing or school supplies are exempt from
taxes for a weekend.
ADP/Taxware receives referrals from both Big Four and individual accountants
with new clients, changes in personnel in their tax departments or expanding to more markets, increasing potential exposure.
Firms sometimes ask for a proposal, which the vendor provides for free, and help the vendor
answer initial questions so clients don't have to, or ADP conducts an in-depth scope analysis, for a cost. The point is, many
accountants need help in order to give help.
"When we reach out to firms, the first step is to understand their level of awareness and increase the risk management
and refund opportunity so they can evaluate their clients and figure out which ones are at risk," says Doug
McCubbin managing director of the AlliantGroup, which provides
tax advisory services to firms and their clients. "Most are comfortable in their own states but miss other opportunities for
credit and incentives. Unless you spend a lot of money on technology to stay on top of it, there's room for lots of errors."
When clients do ask about technology, accountants should first ask about the company's functional requirements and which
of those functions they have in their existing software before considering purchasing a new system, he says.
Some firms simply call AlliantGroup and ask questions which AlliantGroup
charges an hourly fee to answer, but 99 percent of the time AlliantGroup talks directly to the client because
a majority of projects will require revisiting down the road, McCubbin says. And
it's not only the small firms that need help.
Eide Bailly has more than a dozen offices and formed a SALT group about two
years ago with seven employees. But since so many companies are crossing state lines these days, this year the company aligned
with AlliantGroup to serve as national specialists and to help Eide
Bailly with projects related to reverse sales tax audits-aka refund reviews-for clients who may have collected
more tax than they needed to. AlliantGroup charges the firm and the firm charges
the client without marking up the price, but adds fees for any time spent on the project.
"We get more client work, gain experience and we're aware of everything that's happening," says Travis
W. Burgess, CPA, senior tax manager at Eide Bailly.
The firm has plans to develop the specialty services in house down the road as a result of this relationship, he says.
"People feel like they're failing if they can't do everything. The one-stop shop has always been promoted as a
great term, but maybe it's not the best way," Burgess says, echoing Yetter's sentiments. "We let the client be aware there
are issues and let them know we have outside sources and connections that will benefit them even though we don't have the
Alexandra DeFelice is Associate Editor of Accounting Technology and can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.